Are Carfax reports ever wrong?

Despite the vast number of resources available, CARFAX vehicle history reports should not be considered completely reliable. There's just no way that one of these reports can be all-inclusive. In fact, we have found major problems with some CARFAX vehicle history reports.
Click to see full answer

What happens if you buy a car with the wrong mileage?Odometer Fraud Laws
If the odometer mileage is incorrect, the law requires a statement to that effect to be furnished on the title to the buyer. However, a vehicle is exempt from the written disclosure requirements if it's 20 years old or older, or a model year 2010 vehicle or older.

Can a Carfax report be wrong?

If you think there is an error on a CARFAX Vehicle History Report for a vehicle you do not own, please ask the owner of the vehicle to contact us to fix any incorrect information.

Can Carfax be wrong about accident?

In an email, Carfax said, "A review of additional data supported removing the accident." They say they pull information from more than 112,000 sources and that sometimes can lead to errors. "I get the point, you know, to see what damages are on vehicles. Like if it was in a flood or anything like that.

How do you fix CARFAX mileage inconsistency?

If you find mistakes, dispute them at support.carfax.com. You must do it via email online; disputing is not available by phone. Click on "consumer support" in the lower right-hand corner and use the easy upload link to attach your insurance claim to support your position.

Related Questions

Is there anything better than Carfax?

The most significant difference between AutoCheck and CarFax is that AutoCheck is far better at tracking auction cars, while CarFax is known for not being able to effectively track cars at auctions.

Can Carfax be wrong about mileage?

No, CARFAX does not guarantee odometer readings. If a more recent odometer reading is less than an older reading, then the odometer may have been tampered with and ""rolled back"". CARFAX analyzes the mileage history and the sources of this information to indicate a potential odometer rollback or mileage inconsistency.

Can I selling a car with mileage discrepancy?

Federal and State laws require all dealers to disclose any type of odometer discrepancy to all future buyers before the sale. Most states have an Odometer Disclosure Statement that will allow you to report any type of odometer discrepancy.

Can mileage correction be detected?

However, it cannot detect mileage correction issues as the calculations that it makes are based on assumptions rather than calculations.

How do I dispute a Carfax report?

Carfax says that for every 10,000 reports they receive, six are updated or corrected based on information from consumers. You can dispute their vehicle history by contacting the Carfax product support team here. If you have a consumer problem you can't resolve, submit your information at this form.

Is Carfax the best report?

Despite being the most expensive service, the Carfax report is the benchmark for all other vehicle history reports. We've found it to be the most detailed and user-friendly among the vehicle history reports we tested. If a vehicle has had multiple owners, that's clearly labeled and organized in different sections.

How do I remove an accident from Carfax?

How to Remove Information From Carfax

  1. Access the vehicle's Carfax report online and examine the report closely.
  2. Gather any evidence to support your claim that the item is incorrect and should be removed.
  3. Visit the Carfax corrections claim center online.

More items

What does it mean when Carfax says mileage inconsistency?

If a more recent odometer reading is less than an older reading, then the odometer may have been tampered with and ""rolled back"". CARFAX analyzes the mileage history and the sources of this information to indicate a potential odometer rollback or mileage inconsistency.

What does inconsistent mileage mean on Carfax?

A NAM title is issued when an owner (past or current) notifies the DMV of mileage fraud, a broken odometer or that the actual mileage of the vehicle is unknown. If a vehicle is flagged as having a "mileage inconsistency", Carfax recommends verifying the mileage with the dealer or a qualified mechanic.

What is the most accurate vehicle history report?

CarFax is said to have a better record of verifying mileage and reporting the number of owners a car has had. AutoCheck includes an “AutoCheck Score” for a car's history. AutoCheck has also better information on auction cars because it has exclusive access to auction data.

Is AutoCheck better than Carfax?

Carfax reports are more comprehensive than AutoCheck — unlike AutoCheck, they include information on any maintenance or service that was reported. But all of this information comes at a cost — Carfax reports are pricier than AutoCheck reports.

Should I buy a car with mileage discrepancy?

Make sure you compare the mileage on the title and the History Report with the mileage on the odometer. If you spot any discrepancy, especially if the title's mileage is higher than the others, ask the seller to explain it. Ask for some physical maintenance records or inspection records collected by the seller.

How do you tell if mileage has been altered?

Fingerprints on the inside of the glass or around the odometer are evidence of tampering. This may happen if the vehicle was in an accident, and the odometer needed to be replaced, usually indicated by a sticker with the date and last reading of the old odometer.

Can a Carfax report be altered?

The dealer may alter the Carfax report to make the vehicle's title appear clean. The dealer may not be responsible for the inaccuracies on the Carfax report; however, he may have had reason to believe that the information was false.

Can you dispute Carfax?

Carfax says that for every 10,000 reports they receive, six are updated or corrected based on information from consumers. You can dispute their vehicle history by contacting the Carfax product support team here. If you have a consumer problem you can't resolve, submit your information at this form.

Categories:

QA